Different interpretations of the poem

I  prefer the third interpretation even if it's the longer. I think it is the more interessting one and it gives us the desire to travel, to go on Ireland. The poem makes sens with this video.

For my part, it’s difficult to choose because the three interpretations are very brilliant but I think that I prefer the first interpretation. I like his way to say the poem : his intonation, his throughput, the silences… He lives the text and gives emotions. Then, the music and pictures are very pretty.

I prefer the third like poem. Because I think, it is the better to interpret the poem, and with this video, we can to understand the meaning of the poem. Then, for me, the woman has a better articulation than the men.
Morever, the images of poem, represent the road of the poem to Robert Frost, and the two last tanzas was interpreted besser than the fisrt or second because we see, in the third, the true of the poem.
Marine Lagier

I prefer the first interpretation because it's the most calming. Even if the tune in the background makes me sad and nostalgic this interpretation is the most realistic. Besides, the poem is perfectly illustated by the images because they are in link with the woods

I have chosen the first one interpretation of the poem because i find that is the most realistic in relation to the lyrics, and when i listen this I understand better the sense of this poem.

The three interpretation are nice, but for me it's the third which is the best. Even if it's the longest, I find her beautiful and full of emotion. Indeed, the tune in background is soothing and make us travel. And the intonation who take the speaker is apropriate whith the video.

It was so hard to choose between the first and the third interpretation. In fact, I chose the third one only because I had to choose one. The first video is so melancolic, the music is soothing and the pictures of the wood are just wonderful. Plus, it is the one that corresponds the most with the poem (because of the wood's pictures). I was overcome with emotions. However, the third video is even more fascinating. The Ireland landscapes are sooo amazing, it is a real pleasure for eyes. But the video clip does not show the wood whereas it is the main theme.

I prefer the first video because I really like the way it is read and I think that the pictures, music and the voice of the readers combines really well

It was a little bit difficult to choose between the first and the third video. According to me, the first interpretation is really touchy and poetic.
Whereas I prefer the third one. That is true that it is a little bit longer, but I think that this interpretation is the prettiest.
First, I think that the music is really relaxing, it allow us to think about the poem but also escape from reality. Then I loved the way the poem was said: The rhythm of storytelling fits well with that music.
Moreover, the landscape in this video are awesome: it makes me want to discover Ireland, like the girl in this video did. In fact, we can see that she is alone but she enjoys travelling. According to me, this video shows that travelling is a good way to discover ourselves, to relax and think about the world.
Alexia

According to me, the 3rd interpretation is the best one because we can identificate with the teenager. In fact, she travels around Ireland and shows us beautiful landscape. For me, it is a really musical poem because of the sweet voice of the girl and because of the soundtrack. There are birds which are singing and music on the piano. Pictures are fantastic and the clip too!!!

Célia

I didn’t really like the second video, it was very plain . I also didn’t like the third one despite having the most beautiful landscapes but I didn’t enjoy how she reads the poem , she took too much time! So therefore, the interpretation I prefer is the first one . I find it very relaxing and touching.

I prefered the thrid one, because it really gives me the envy to travel, and it was not boring like the first one. It was very relaxing, the music helps a lot too. There were also the pictures of beautiful landscapes, which were attractive and catched the attention.

The first interpretation is very interresting. The different pictures of beautiful nature, and the fresh music who accompagnies a voice man ( which by the way is very pleasant to listen) are a very good choice.
Moreover, a feeling of nostaligia can seize us. This reading have a lot of emotions and the Man set the tone, the rhythm and support the important words.
I don’t like to much the second intepretation, because for me the presence of music, and staging is really essential, but they are not here. And, with the poem under the eyes, we are less interested by Robert frost’s pronouciation.
Despite the fact that the third video have a very good staging, with a story of a pretty young lady, it’s too long. It’s bad.. and I think that it’s for this, that I prefer the first interpretation.

I prefer 3rd interpretation because it's very calm and I think the music behind speech is the most appropriate to be with this text. I think it is a music to reflect

Yes, it's really hard to choose between the three interpretations ! I had chosen the first one but the three videos are good. The third video is really great : the tone is right, the pictures are beautiful, the music is soft... And the second video is good too. It is simple but true.

The three interpretations are different, so it's difficult to choose...